U-PHIL: "So you want to do a philosophical analysis?"

“Philosophy, as I have so far understood and lived it, means living voluntarily among ice and high mountains—seeking out everything strange and questionable in existence”. Nietzsche*
I am about to turn to philosophical analyses/deconstructions of short portions of articles from the special issue “Statistical Science and Philosophy of Science” (RMM 2011),  and I will invite contributed analyses from readers and, of course, the author(s).  The first text, to be posted tomorrow, will be from Professor Stephen Senn. (Full article)
 I will post some (after a week or so) as with the last “deconstruction” exercise.
Since we’ve been at this for a while, I’m assuming that you’re anxious to try out your philosophical muscles. So, to begin, hold (a portion of) the text at “arm’s length,” as it were. Cycle around it, slowly. Give it a generous interpretation, then cycle around it again self-critically. Try and challenge the text but also your initial impressions, give reasons, maybe include some pondering “aloud” of what you wrote. 

Stop there. Or, try to imaginatively consider how to push the problem/argument a bit further: Which of the assumptions are shaky? What are the gaps? How would it advance the author’s goal to fill them?

If you don’t typically write philosophy, then this little exercise should produce something that feels a bit strange, even foreign. But it should be fun, and Lou Salome is saying that it would be good for you.
*Contest: Nietzsche readers will immediately find the single most glaring error in this famous (posed) picture.  What is it?
Categories: philosophy of science, U-Phil | Tags: , | 3 Comments

Post navigation

3 thoughts on “U-PHIL: "So you want to do a philosophical analysis?"

  1. I’m rather surprised that no one has won the Nietzsche contest yet—I feel like I’ve gotten away with something…and the photo looks so much better this way….

    • Xi'an

      Where is Paul Ree???

      • Yes! Another q point goes to Christian Robert (I do plan to pay up at some point). I felt that Ree kind of ruins the picture.
        As I recall, after this friendly period was long over, Nietzsche, jealous that Ree had stolen Lou away, and slipping into insanity, wrote that he wanted to teach Ree a lesson in morality with the help of a few bullets.

        by the way, I didn’t use photo shop which we don’t have here on the island, but rather printed out the pic, snipped it in a few places, and drew over to let Ree’s right arm appear to be Nietzsche’s. Also made the mountains bigger and higher.

I welcome constructive comments for 14-21 days

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Blog at WordPress.com. The Adventure Journal Theme.

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 480 other followers