The following is my commentary on a paper by Gelman and Robert, forthcoming (in early 2013) in the The American Statistician* (submitted October 3, 2012). _______________________ Discussion of Gelman and Robert, “Not only defended but also applied”: The perceived absurdity of Bayesian inference” Deborah G. Mayo 1. Introduction I am grateful for the chance to comment on the paper by … Continue reading Mayo Commentary on Gelman & Robert